#28152 I am going to attempt to organize my thoughts on the
#takeaknee protest to offer a prospective that I think is being argued but not articulated.
To begin my argument, I want you to think abstractly about the national anthem. At face value, it is a song we play to represent our country. Obviously, it stands for much more than this to many people than if it were some sort of pledge of fealty. Specifically to myself, the anthem, the flag, and feelings of patriotism are reserved for the abstract spirit of America- that is the ethereal spirit of a government of the people, navigating the seas of the most diverse population on earth and attempting to find the objective truth and objective good for as many of its people as possible. Of course, we have not had a clean ride. Our past is riddled with unquestionable darkness.There are many injustices that still take place in America, and we must discuss them. But by kneeling for our anthem, one says "I disregard the tradition of respect for any and all progress that has been made in an attempt to bring to light the issues." No matter how noble your cause, you have now alienated everyone who believes the spirit of America can and will prevail through current inequalities. You are offensive for the same reason that burning the flag is offensive, because you have opened yourself to being interpreted as disrespectful to any and everything the anthem can inspire. An action causes a reaction, and by stating 'no, it means this' is no different than people justifying flying the confederate flag for southern pride when it can be taken as the symbol for an institution of slavery. You are being inconsiderate, tone-deaf, and blantantly ignorant to think that this can't be seen as affront to everything positive there is left to be found in being American.
We, as a nation, are only as divided as we perceive ourselves to be. To kneel during the anthem is to say to many that the infinite number of interpretations of the anthem are no longer possible of deserving your individual respect. Regardless of the virtue behind your gesture, the gesture in itself is offensive to anyone that believes in America's people and her ability to change, regardless of any type partisan stance.
tl;dr: the mechanism of delivery sucks.